Skip to main content

Raped Indian nurse dies after 42 years in coma

Aruna Shanbaug, who suffered
severe brain damage during Mumbai
attack, prompts debate about India's
euthanasia laws

The death of an Indian nurse who was in a
coma for 42 years after being sexually
assaulted while working in a hospital has
prompted a renewed debate on
euthanasia in the country.
Aruna Shanbaug suffered severe brain
damage and was in a vegetative state after
she was raped and strangled with a dog
chain by a hospital sweeper in Mumbai,
the Indian commercial capital, in 1973.
She was 25.
Shanbaug was diagnosed with pneumonia
last week and had been on a life-support
system for the past few days, said Pravin
Bangar, medical superintendent at the
city's King Edward Memorial hospital.
Her case first sparked arguments over
India's euthanasia laws after Pinki Virani,
a Mumbai-based author and friend of the
nurse, petitioned the courts to stop force-
feeding her through a tube so her
suffering would not be prolonged.
In 2011, India's supreme court rejected a
petition filed by Virani, who had sought
euthanasia for Shanbaug, saying the court
should "end her unbearable agony".
However the bench of two judges did say
that "passive euthanasia" would be
permitted under certain circumstances,
but only if, in the case of Shanbaug, the
hospital itself made the request.
"Aruna Shanbaug's parents are dead and
other close relatives have not been
interested in her ever since she had the
unfortunate assault on her," the judgment
read. "It is the KEM hospital staff, who
have been amazingly caring for her day
and night for so many long years, who
really are her next friends ... Hence it is
for [them] to take that decision."
The case had been opposed by nurses at
the hospital, who cared for Shanbaug for
more than four decades after her family
said they were unable to support her.
They celebrated the judgment as a
"rebirth" of Shanbaug.
The nurse's death has now provoked
renewed calls for the law to be reviewed.
On the Firstpost news website on
Monday, editor-in-chief R Jagannathan
said the "time for more waffle on assisted
suicide is over".
"We need a proper law on euthanasia
with strong safeguards. The right to die
with dignity is an inalienable part of the
right to life," Jagannathan wrote.
Senior medical staff who have overseen
Shanbaug's care have described
euthanasia as a western concept which is
not easily accepted in India. On Monday,
several told reporters that they were
relieved the nurse had died a "natural
death".
"We look at life differently. Our culture
believes in nurturing life till the end. And
we will care for Aruna till the very end,"
Shubhangi Parkar, dean of the hospital,
told the Times of India newspaper last
year.
Shanbaug's attacker served a seven-year
sentence in prison after being convicted
of robbery and attempted murder after
evidence of penetration was removed
from a medical report.

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Windows 10 now on 600 million machines.

Microsoft CEO Satya Nadella told shareholders that Windows 10 has now passed 600 million monthly active users, picking up 100 million since May of this year. This number counts all Windows 10 devices used over a 28-day period. While most of these will be PCs, there are other things in the mix there: a few million Xbox Ones, a few million Windows 10 Mobile phones, and special hardware like the HoloLens and Surface Hub. The exact mix between these categories isn't known, because Microsoft doesn't say. The company's original ambition (and sales pitch to developers) was to have one billion systems running Windows 10 within about three years of the operating system's launch. In July last year, the company acknowledged that it won't hit that target—the original plan called for  50 million or more phone sales a year , which the retreat from the phone market has made impossible. But at the current rate it should still be on track for somewhere in excess of 700 million use...

WZoneLite – A Pretty Cool WooCommerce Amazon Affiliate Plugin .

Everyone wants to make a million dollars by being a blogger. The promise of riches and internet fame is a big draw to doing it for a lot of people, and I’m sorry to say that the reality of being a blogger (even a professional blogger!) is not quite…as financially lucrative as all that. But that’s not to say that it  can’t be –one of the best ways to start your empire is with an Amazon affiliate plugin. For me, the Amazon Associates program has been one of the biggest earners for me over the years. Not only are there CPM ads like Google Adsense (you know, the normal banner ads we all love to hate), but any time someone clicks a link from your site, you get a percentage of  anything  they buy while the token from your site lasts in their browser. If they buy a song, you get a few cents. If they buy a new MacBook Pro and iPhone? You get…a lot more cents. With that in mind, WZoneLite is a  pretty cool WooCommerce Amazon affiliate plugin that syncs everything together s...

How Antacids And PPI’s Can Destroy Your Health DRUG DANGER ALERT

New Science Shows Hidden, Deadly Risk Of Common Heartburn And Reflux Drugs   Dear Heartburn Sufferer, If you take any over-the-counter drug for your acid reflux, heartburn, or GERD... including Prevacid and Prilosec,... this timely report directly affects you. So take thirty seconds and read every word of this email. Carefully. These commonly used drugs suffered a major setback recently when the FDA warned that taking them can give you a dangerous condition known as "C-Diff". Now there is evidence to show Prilosec, Prevacid, and other PPI's ("Proton Pump Inhibitors") ... or the other common group of drugs for reflux called "antacids"... create another, potentially greater risk to your health. It seems antacids and PPI's are literally starving your body of vital nutrients, and leading to all sorts of deadly health conditions. Some conditions that have beenlinked to these drugs: Dementia Irregular heartbeat Iron deficie...